Understanding Why Christians Jump From Church To Church
Church leaders pour their hearts into people.
They preach, pray, and provide support.
Yet, some stay. Some stray. And some simply slip away.
Few things frustrate pastors more than church hoppers—those who move from one congregation to another, never planting roots, never fully committing.
It’s not just an attendance issue—it’s a leadership burden that drains energy, disrupts discipleship, and weakens church culture.
The 4 Types of Churchgoers
Every church has four types of attendees:
1️⃣ The Hoppers – Jump from church to church, always searching, never settling.
2️⃣ The Shoppers – Treat church like a marketplace, consuming but not contributing.
3️⃣ The Droppers – Disengage completely, keeping their faith but leaving the fellowship.
4️⃣ The Rockers – The faithful few who stay, serve, and strengthen the church.
Too many Hoppers, Shoppers, and Droppers.
Not enough Rockers.
And pastors are paying the price.
Why Church Hopping Hurts Leaders
❌ Drains Discipleship – Pastors invest in people who leave before they grow.
❌ Weakens Worship – Shallow commitment leads to surface-level faith.
❌ Exhausts Energy – The constant churn of new faces and lost members wears leaders down.
It’s hard to build momentum when people keep moving.
It’s hard to grow leaders when they won’t stay long enough to develop.
It’s hard to shepherd a flock when the sheep keep switching pastures.
The Deeper Problem
Most pastors assume church hoppers are just spiritually immature or commitment-phobic.
But the truth is more complex.
Many are:
🔹 Searching for depth – They leave when they don’t feel spiritually challenged.
🔹 Seeking connection – They move on when relationships feel surface-level.
🔹 Avoiding conflict – They disappear instead of working through hard conversations.
Hopping isn’t always about disloyalty—sometimes it’s about disconnection.
How to Create More Church Rockers
1️⃣ Clarify Commitment – Teach that church isn’t a service to attend, but a family to belong to.
2️⃣ Strengthen Systems – Build discipleship pathways that move people from visitor to vested.
3️⃣ Deepen Relationships – People don’t leave where they feel truly known.
4️⃣ Challenge Consumers – Shift culture from passive participation to active ownership.
When people feel spiritually fed, relationally connected, and personally challenged, they stay, serve, and strengthen the body of Christ.
Get the Blueprint to Fix It
Pew Patterns: Why The Saints Are Sittin’, Switchin’, and Searchin’ is 4 books in 1—a complete guide to:
✅ Stop the cycle of church hopping, shopping, and dropping
✅ Build a culture of commitment, connection, and contribution
✅ Turn more attendees into Church Rockers—leaders who last
Fewer Hoppers.
Fewer Shoppers.
Fewer Droppers.
More Rockers.
Pew Patterns launches 3.27.25!
Eric V Hampton
Whenever you’re ready, there are 5 ways I can help you:
Coaching. Transform your core leaders into a high-performing team that increases creativity, productivity, and profitability.
ChurchLeaderOS. My leadership development “operating system” equips every member to become a high-capacity leader.
The Healthy Church Leader Annual Review. My annual review guides you from celebration (remembering past wins) to expectation (planning future wins) as you pursue your Christ-centered mission.
The Real MVP. I wrote and designed this book to invest in your leadership. Become a person of mission, vision, and purpose in 60 minutes.